Warning: SPOILERS ahead for A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.
Summary
A Good Girl’s Guide to Murderrevolves around two deaths that occurred in the town of Little Kilton five years earlier, butthe Netflix series features another tragedy in its present-day timeline. While Pip investigates thedisappearance of Andie Bell, she receives threats telling her to stop asking questions.A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder’s endingreveals that these warnings are coming from two different people. And one of them goes so far as to kidnap Andie’s dog in response to her snooping.
Pip is shown interacting with Barney numerous times throughout the Netflix series, making it clear that the Fitz-Amobi family’s dog is an important member of their household. The love Pip and her family have for Barney makes his death inA Good Girl’s Guide to Murdermuch more tragic. AndBarney meets his untimely end because of the same person who killed Andie Bell. It’s no surprise she’s willing to go after Pip’s dog, as she has a lot to lose if the truth is discovered.
A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder’s Biggest Max Hastings Change Gives Me Hope For Season 2
It’s unclear if A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder season 2 will happen, but the Netflix series’ biggest Max Hastings change gives me hope it will.
Becca Bell Killed Pip’s Dog Barney In A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder
Andie’s Sister Wanted Pip To Stop Investigating
Andie’s sister, Becca Bell, is the one that kills her inA Good Girl’s Guide to Murder— andshe’s also the reason Barney dies in the present-day story. Becca seems like a background character for much of the Netflix series, but her role in Andie’s death is more significant than the show initially lets on. Becca obviously wants Pip to drop her investigation, so she takes Barney and blackmails Pip using her leverage.
Since Barney winds up dead after Becca steals him,it’s safe to assume she’s the one who kills Pip’s dog in the Netflix show. However, the series never shows this — and in Holly Jackson’s book, things are more complicated. Becca still kidnaps Barney in the source material, but she claims that she didn’t really want to kill him. Barney falls in a river in the novel, after Becca lets him go. This is one of thechangesA Good Girl’s Guide to Murdermakesto the book. However, in both versions of the story, Barney dies due to Becca’s actions.
Why Becca Killed Barney & How She Secretly Took Him
Pip’s Social Media Post Caused Becca To Panic
Becca kidnaps Barney to get Pip to drop her investigation, as she doesn’t want to be exposed as Andie’s true killer. Killing Barney seems like an extreme length to go to, but Pip doesn’t heed any of Becca’s prior warnings. AndPip’s social media post about Andie causes Becca to panic, leading her to go after someone Pip loves. Becca’s actions almost have the desired effect, too. Pip briefly considers dropping the investigation at Ravi’s request. Fortunately, she doesn’t, as she gets a major clue at the end ofA Good Girl’s Guide to Murder.
Becca kidnaps Barney to get Pip to drop her investigation, as she doesn’t want to be exposed as Andie’s true killer.
As for how Becca got her hands on Barney, that’s anyone’s guess. The series doesn’t show her kidnapping the dog, but Barney disappears during Pip’s brother’s birthday party. It seems Becca uses this distraction to make her move. The festivities prevent Pip from noticing that Barney is missing, so Becca’s plan works.A Good Girl’s Guide to Murdersprings this tragedy on Pip, forcing her to take the threats she’s getting a bit more seriously.
A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder
Cast
Pip Fitz-Amobi, a determined young investigator, is set on uncovering the truth behind schoolgirl Andie Bell’s murder five years prior. Sal Singh, Andie’s boyfriend, confessed before his own death, but Pip doesn’t believe he’s guilty. Teaming up with Sal’s brother Ravi, she dives into a web of secrets to find the real killer.
