Spencer MacPherson and Kiara Pichardo discuss Nicole and Xavier’s storyline inSchool Spiritsseason 2. The series, which premiered on Paramount+ in 2023, follows Maddie (Peyton List), a teen girl stuck in the afterlife, as she investigates her own mysterious disappearance while navigating school as a new spirit. Nicole and Xavier, portrayed by MacPherson and Pichardo respectively, have shown romantic and platonic tension throughoutSchool Spiritsseasons 1 and 2.

During an interview withScreenRant,both actors teased the continuation of their “You’ve Got Mail” dynamic, which refers to a romantic arc where two people, unaware of their real identities, develop a deep connection through anonymity, particularly with messages exchanged under pseudonyms. MacPherson mentioned that Xavier’s reluctance to open up and connect with others makes this anonymous exchange a crucial step for his personal growth. Pichardo echoed the sentiment, stating that the mystery surrounding their communication leaves room for unexpected twists. Check out their comments below:

Imogen from Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin, Maddie from School Spirits, and Sabrina from Chilling Adventures of Sabrina

Spencer MacPherson:Great reference [re: You’ve Got Mail]. Oh gosh, I don’t know what I can say.

Kiara Pichardo:I don’t know where it’s going to go. I guess that’s a question for the writers. But I think it’s kind of cool the way they did it in the sense of, they’re talking, but they don’t know who the other is, so it could really go any way.

School Spirits' cast, led by Peyton List.

Spencer MacPherson:I think for Xavier, he’s very much afraid to open up to people, afraid to let his walls down, and this sort of, “You’ve Got Mail” situation enables him to be himself around someone, and I think that that’s a really important thing for him. I don’t know where it leads, but I know that it’s good for him.

What This Means For Nicole & Xavier’s Storyline In School Spirits

Xavier And Nicole Have A Slow-Burn Dynamic

Nicole and Xavier’s latest relationship development represents a shift in howSchool Spiritsaddresses its character arcs. By usingtheYou’ve Got Mailformat,the writers are able to explore their emotional chemistry without requiring immediate face-to-face interactions.This dynamic allows both characters to reveal more of themselves than they would if they were speaking in person, paying mind to their vulnerabilities and personal growth. For Xavier, he has a safer space to open up, something he’d previously struggled with due to his fears of emotional exposure caused by his near-death experience after being hit by a truck.

10 Best Shows Like School Spirits

The smash hit series, School Spirits, is a supernatural teen drama with mass appeal, and there are plenty of other TV shows just like it.

For Nicole, their ongoing communication offers an interesting opportunity to deepen her curiosity and openness, along with her backstory. The mystery surrounding Xavier’s identity, from her perspective at least, emphasizes her truest self and how she acts. This approach also highlights the writers' commitment to pushing boundaries in character development, ensuring that the interactions hold weight. Moreover, it cankeep viewers engaged as they wait for the eventual reveal between Nicole and Xavier, and the subsequent impact on both characters' evolutions.

School Spirits TV Poster

Our Take On MacPherson And Pichardo’s Comments

We’re Excited To See How Nicole Aand Xavier’s Relationship Unfolds

By allowing Nicole and Xavier to communicate incognito,School Spiritsexplores the deep level of emotional vulnerability between its characters. For Xavier, the opportunity to connect without fear of judgment presents a unique moment of growth, which could allow for more complicated developments later in season 2. While the mystery of their identities adds an element of suspense, it also reflects how relationships can flourish in unconventional ways. It’s a clever narrative choice that keepsthe audience invested in both characters' journeys,ultimately enrichingSchool Spirits' intrigue.