American Idolseason 23’s newest judge, Carrie Underwood, has become one of the biggest draws of the season despite some fan backlash during her early appearances, andI think she’s bringing just the right energy to the shownow that she’s gotten into the swing of things. Carrie, who joinedAmerican Idolseason 23after Katy Perry chose to depart after seven seasons, was a major part of the rollout of the season. While Carrie has been receiving some backlash fromAmerican Idolfans, it’s clear that there’s a learning curve in becoming a judge that she had to overcome.
Despite knowing that Carrie is a country megastar who chose to joinAmerican Idolto help bring her talents to the series and aid in building the next generation of artists, many felt that her fame could overshadow the show’s new contestants. WhileCarrie has been working hard as a judge in her own right, she’s also been revisiting her time onAmerican Idolin the process, bringing viewers along with her. After being crowned thewinner ofAmerican Idolseason 4, Carrie took country music by storm, and seeing her back in her element onIdolhas been exciting.
Now that the audition phase has ended, I think Carrie’s improved a lot.
Carrie Faced Fan Backlash During Her First Episodes
She Wasn’t Being Seen As A Good Judge
Although many were excited at theidea of Carrie becoming anAmerican Idoljudgeafter Katy’s departure, her first few episodes were somewhat rocky. After being re-introduced to theIdolviewers, Carrie took her seat at the judge’s table with Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. Unfortunately,her performance wasn’t the best directly out the gate. While some felt she was too tough on the competitors, others felt that she didn’t have enough empathy for those who she was rejecting.
20 Best Reality TV Shows Right Now
Reality TV is more popular than ever. With so many to choose from, here are some of the best reality TV shows to stream or watch right now.
Despite the world having beenready to see Carrie as a judge, her style wasn’t right for someAmerican Idolviewers. As she moved through the audition rounds,Carrie’s judging was tough to watch in moments, as she continuously overstepped her boundaries and struggled to make her criticisms appear valid. Though her time as a judge had been short, manyAmerican Idolviewers quickly clocked in to try and prove that she wasn’t right for the job.
Carrie’s Judging Style Hasn’t Been Consistent
She’s Been Shifting Things Around
While manyIdolviewers have known Carrie since her original run on the show, it’s much different to see her in her own spotlight than onAmerican Idol.Carrie has become a superstar since her time on the series, which has deeply colored her perspective about fame and talent. WithCarrie’s judging being called out early oninAmerican Idolseason 23’s run, it was clear that she wasn’t giving consistent criticism, which seemed like a problem.Carrie was sometimes overly emotional, and sometimes incredibly detached, which made things more difficult for viewers to adjust to on the show.
Carrie’s Energy Is Making Contestants More Comfortable
She’s Fostering Community With Competitors
American Idolhas been exciting for Carrie, and though she had a tough time in the first few episodes, I think her energy has shifted as things have progressed in the competition. WhileCarrie’s nerves may have gotten the best of her in the early episodes of the season, now that the audition phase has ended, I think Carrie’s improved a lot. Her excited energy throughout the last Hollywood week episode was palpable, and she was able to share her own experiences a bit more thoroughly with contestants.American Idol’sCarrie’s perspective has shifted, making her far better on screen.
