The fierce rivalry betweenDCandMarvelis no secret, with both comic giants constantly competing—and their fanbases just as eager to debate which universe has the best characters. One of the biggest arguments? Who reigns supreme as the best female superhero. Now, thanks to a deep dive into Google Trends, fans finally have a definitive answer straight from the people themselves.
…it was surprising to see Supergirl and Batgirl each claim only one state, considering their traditionally strong popularity.
To determine the most popular female superhero in the United States,PrivacyJournal.net—a digital resource specializing in online privacy, cybersecurity, and digital safety—conducted a comprehensive analysis using Google Trends data from the past 12 months.
By examining search trends, they identified the most searched-for female superhero in each state, revealing a clear winner. While 10 different heroines claimed the top spot in various states,one dominated by a landslide, ranking as the most searched in 31 states—Wonder Woman.
Wonder Woman Dominates as Most Popular Female Superhero in the USA
Main Cover by Daniel Sampere & Tomeu Morey for Tom King’sWonder Woman#14 (2024)
Wonder Woman’s overwhelming popularity was evident in PrivacyJournal.net’s findings, asshe ranked as the most searched female superhero in 31 out of 50 states, primarily dominating the Midwest and Northeast. The states where Wonder Woman came out on top include Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Utah, Colorado, New Mexico, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, Missouri, Iowa, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Mississippi, Alabama, Tennessee, Kentucky, Indiana, Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Delaware, New York, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Connecticut, and Hawaii. With such a staggering geographic reach, Wonder Woman has once again proven that she isn’t justDC’s premier heroine—she’s a dominant force across all of comics.
Diana’s stronghold over 31 states reinforces the lasting power of her 80-year legacy, a popularity undoubtedly bolstered by the success of theWonder Womanfilms starring Gal Gadot.Her presence across both liberal-leaning and conservative states highlights her ability to transcend political divides, making her a universally beloved hero. However, one surprising exception stands out—Wonder Woman did not claim Washington D.C., a territory she frequently operates out of in both comics and films. Instead, Captain Marvel took the top spot in the nation’s capital, marking an interesting factoid in popularity.
Who Are the Other Top-Ranking Female Superheroes in the United States?
Graphics Are Courtesy of PrivateJournal.Net (The Most Popular Female Superhero in Each State – Who Reigns Supreme?)
The data gathered by PrivacyJournal.net goes beyond just identifying the most popular female superhero—it also provides insight into the runners-up. While no heroine came close to matching Wonder Woman’s dominance, several still made a strong showing across various states.Starfire, Captain Marvel, Black Widow, Jessica Jones, Invisible Woman, Power Girl, Valkyrie, Batgirl, and Supergirl each claimed at least one state.Coming insecond place was DC’s Starfire, who secured six states—Arizona, Georgia, Maryland, Michigan, South Carolina, and Vermont. Her popularity undoubtedly stems from her Teen Titans fanbase, but her presence on this list suggests her appeal extends beyond her team affiliations.
Following Starfire was Captain Marvel, who claimed Florida, Montana, North Dakota, and the District of Columbia. Black Widow locked down three states—Louisiana, Wyoming, and Massachusetts—while Jessica Jones took Nevada and Illinois. The remaining heroines each dominated a single state: Invisible Woman in Alaska, Power Girl in California, Valkyrie in Maine, Batgirl in Texas, and Supergirl in New Jersey. With an even split of five heroines from both DC and Marvel making the list, DC ultimately emerged as the clear leader in female superhero popularity, thanks to Wonder Woman’s overwhelming 31-state sweep and Starfire’s strong six-state presence.
Captain Marvel Has Serious Potential But One Piece of Baggage Keeps the Hero Tied Down
Captain Marvel has a lackluster history, leading some readers to question why she hasn’t lived up to her full potential, and how that could change.
Supergirl & Batgirl Were Shockingly Unpopular (But This Could Change)
Main Cover by Bilquis Evely & Mat Lopes for Tom King’sSupergirl: Woman of Tomorrow#1 (2021)
While Wonder Woman claiming the top spot as the most popular female superhero was expected—given her status alongside Batman and Superman—it was surprising to see Supergirl and Batgirl each claim only one state, considering their traditionally strong popularity. This shift suggests an evolving fan preference when it comes to female heroes. However, with James Gunn’sSupergirl: Woman of Tomorrowset to release in 2026, the film could reignite interest in the heroine and boost her popularity, even if she doesn’t quite reachWonder Woman’slevel.
